Recently, the Los Angeles Unified School District passed a policy that no more than 10% of a student's grade can come from homework. The school distrcit has sited that not all children have a equal homework environment. Since not all students have an equal homework environment, applying more than 10% of a weight is not fair or equitable. Many teachers are not in agreement with this approach, including myself. If you restrict all teachers to a 10% benchmark, many problems can arise. For example, many times homework is given to practice skills taught in class. For some subjects, like mathematics, practice is essential. With homework accounting for only 10% of a student's grade, what incentive do students have to actually complete the homework? Moreover, education is not so cut and dry - not all class are created equal. In a high school English class, for example, students are expected to write essays on different literature. Normally, writing an essay is something that is done outside of class. Class time is generally reserved for discussing the literature, revising, and how to write a paper. Furthermore, students are in school for a limited amount of time which means teachers have a limited time for instruction. When are students supposed to get these assignments done? Not to mention, what are we teaching our students. One day, our students will be in the work force or in college where you have to do outside work. It is better to learn good study habits now. We should be teaching our students to succeed in life. I do not think you can look at education in a homogeneously manner.
Check out this article in the LA Times regarding the new policy:
http://articles.latimes.com/2011/jun/27/local/la-me-homework-20110627
No comments:
Post a Comment